Control, Avoidance or Trust?

I have a trivia team, and we play every Tuesday. It's become a pretty important part of our lives. We go to the same place, sit at the same table, have the same host, and even tend to sit in the same seats around the table.

We've been doing this for years. It's predictable, it's fun, and it gives our week a little rhythm.

We don't particularly like change, either. They changed the cheese on the pizza once, and we decided we weren't getting the pizza anymore!

So, you can imagine our reaction when Henry, our trivia host of 13 years, announced that he would be retiring at the end of the year.

Suddenly, something we had come to rely on was going to change.

What fascinated me wasn't the announcement itself. It was how differently everyone on our team responded.

My friend Roger immediately went into problem-solving mode. He started thinking out loud about who could replace Henry, whether we could move to another night, and how we could keep everything exactly the same. He wanted to solve the problem right away.

My husband and another friend took a different approach. They didn't want to think about it. They were happy to enjoy trivia while it lasted and worry about the future later.

And then there was me. I thought, We have three months left. We'll figure something out. This is either going to work out or something better will come along.

I chose to trust.

Three people, three different responses to the same uncertainty: control, avoidance, and trust.

And here's what I want to explore today: these same responses show up in nonprofit leadership and fundraising all the time.

When a donor doesn't respond, a proposal is sitting unanswered, or a board member isn't following through, how do you react? Do you try to control the situation? Do you avoid it? Or can you trust yourself enough to allow the situation to unfold without abandoning your own responsibility?

Understanding the difference can completely change the way you approach fundraising.

Why Uncertainty Is So Difficult for Nonprofit Leaders

Fundraising requires us to live with uncertainty.

We don't know who will give. We don't know who will respond to our annual appeal. We don't know whether a major donor will move forward, whether a grant will be approved, or whether a relationship we've been nurturing will develop into something meaningful.

And because we care so deeply about our missions, that uncertainty can feel especially uncomfortable.

There are people depending on our organizations. There are programs that need funding. There are communities that need support.

So when something is uncertain, we naturally want to do something about it.

The problem is that sometimes our actions aren't really about moving the relationship forward. They're about making our own discomfort go away.

I want to look at three common responses to uncertainty and how they show up in fundraising.

1. Control: When Responsibility Becomes Pressure

Control is probably the easiest response to justify because it often looks like productivity.

You're following up. You're making calls. You're sending another email. You're checking in with the donor. You're doing everything you can to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.

And those things can absolutely be part of good fundraising.

But sometimes, underneath all that activity, something else is happening.

You're trying to make the uncertainty go away.

When a donor goes quiet, a board member doesn't respond, or a funding decision gets delayed, we can start interpreting that uncertainty as a threat. We want to regain a sense of safety, so we take action.

We send another email. We explain ourselves again. We offer another incentive. We push for a decision.

But here's the distinction I want you to remember:

Action isn't the same as control. Control begins when we're trying to manage something that doesn't belong to us.

You can control whether you make a clear invitation. You cannot control whether someone accepts it.

You can control how you communicate. You cannot control how someone receives your message.

You can control the quality of the relationship you offer. You cannot control another person's willingness to participate.

When Donor Follow-Up Becomes Pressure

I recently had someone in a workshop tell me they had followed up with a donor six times and still hadn't received a response.

They wanted to know what they should do next.

My first question wasn't about how many more times they should follow up.

It was: What are you hoping the seventh email will accomplish?

Are you providing new information? Are you making a useful invitation? Are you helping the donor make an informed decision?

Or are you trying to relieve the anxiety of not knowing?

That's an important distinction.

When your need for certainty becomes more important than another person's freedom to choose, you move from influence to pressure.

And when people feel pressured, they often push back or pull away.

Sometimes, the most respectful thing you can do is acknowledge the lack of response and release the next step to the donor.

You might say:

"I've reached out a few times, so I'll leave it with you for now. If you're still interested, I'm happy to answer any questions or continue the conversation. And if the timing isn't right, that's okay too."

That doesn't mean you don't care about the outcome. It means you understand that the donor gets to make their own decision.

2. Avoidance: When Doing Nothing Isn't the Same as Trusting

Now let's swing to the other side of the pendulum.

If control tries to escape uncertainty by doing more, avoidance tries to escape uncertainty by doing less.

Avoidance can look surprisingly peaceful.

You tell yourself you're giving someone space. You're respecting their process. You're releasing the outcome.

And sometimes you genuinely are.

But sometimes what you're really saying is:

"I'm afraid of what might happen if I act."

You might be afraid of hearing no. You might be afraid of disappointing someone. You might be afraid of having a difficult conversation or discovering that a relationship isn't what you thought it was.

The difference between acceptance and avoidance is important.

Acceptance means seeing reality as it is and responding appropriately.

Avoidance means trying not to experience something uncomfortable.

The Underperforming Board Member

Let's look at a situation I know many nonprofit leaders will recognize.

You have a board member who consistently misses meetings and doesn't follow through on commitments.

You tell yourself that everyone is busy. You want to give them grace. You know they have other responsibilities, and you don't want to make things uncomfortable.

So you don't say anything.

But you also haven't had an honest conversation about the expectations they agreed to when they joined the board.

That may not be compassion. It may be avoidance.

And while you're avoiding the conversation, resentment is building. You're frustrated because the board member isn't contributing, but they may not even realize how their behavior is affecting the organization.

The longer you avoid the conversation, the harder it can become.

Sometimes leadership requires us to have the uncomfortable conversation, establish a boundary, or make a clear request.

Trust doesn't mean you never take action. Sometimes the most trusting thing you can do is finally say what needs to be said.

3. Trust: Staying Present Without Certainty

Now, let's talk about trust.

I want to make an important distinction here because we often misunderstand what trust actually means.

We think trust means believing everything will work out the way we want.

"I trust the donor will say yes."

"I trust the board will come around."

"I trust this funding opportunity will happen."

But that's really a prediction about an outcome.

What happens to your trust when the donor says no? What happens when the board doesn't agree? What happens when the opportunity doesn't materialize?

If your trust depends on getting the outcome you want, then you're not really trusting yourself. You're trusting a prediction.

Trust is the ability to stay present without certainty.

It's knowing that you can make a thoughtful decision, act in alignment with your values, and respond to whatever happens next.

You don't need to know how the story ends to participate in it fully.

You can make the invitation. You can have the conversation. You can establish the boundary. You can say yes. You can say no.

And you can allow someone else to make their own choices.

This is what I mean when I talk about releasing the outcome.

It doesn't mean you stop caring. It means you stop believing that you have to control the outcome in order to be okay.

I often remind myself: I'm not going to be okay. I am okay.

That is a very different way of approaching uncertainty.

Trusting Yourself Means Respecting the Sovereignty of Others

We talk about sovereignty quite a bit on this podcast.

Your sovereignty is your ability to make choices for yourself. You define your own value and worth. You decide what you accept and what you don't.

But genuine trust also requires us to respect that same sovereignty in other people.

A donor has the right to say yes. A donor has the right to say no. They have the right to decide that the timing isn't right, that another priority matters more, or that they don't want to participate.

Their decision does not define your value as a fundraiser.

Whether a donor gives or doesn't give doesn't prove anything about who you are, how good you are at your job, or how much your work matters.

If I trust myself, I don't need to control you.

If I respect your sovereignty, I don't need to interpret your no as a failure of my influence.

And if I trust my ability to navigate disappointment, I don't have to avoid situations where disappointment is possible.

This is especially important in fundraising because we can become so focused on closing the deal that we forget the person on the other side of the relationship.

We want them to give. We want them to participate. We want them to say yes.

And it's okay to want those things.

But wanting something deeply doesn't mean you have to control someone else to make it happen.

The Edge of Your Agency: Knowing What Is Yours to Do

Here's an idea I want you to think about when you're navigating donor relationships: the edge of your agency.

Every relationship has a boundary between what belongs to you and what belongs to someone else.

On your side of that boundary are:

  • Your intentions.

  • Your words and actions.

  • Your willingness to communicate clearly.

  • Your invitations and requests.

  • Your agreements and boundaries.

  • Your response to whatever happens next.

On the other person's side are their timing, readiness, feelings, priorities, and decisions.

Your responsibility is to go all the way to the edge of your agency, but not beyond it.

If you don't go far enough, you may be avoiding your responsibility. Perhaps you haven't made the invitation, asked the question, or had the necessary conversation.

But if you cross over into someone else's agency, you stop offering influence and start applying pressure.

What This Looks Like in Fundraising

Imagine you've been cultivating a major donor.

You've taken the time to understand their interests, shared information about your organization, answered their questions, and made a thoughtful invitation to support your work.

The donor tells you they aren't ready to give this year.

You've done your part.

You can acknowledge their decision, let them know you're available if they have questions, and leave the relationship open.

But what happens when your executive director or fundraising committee says, "You can't just accept that. Go back and get something from them"?

This is where things get complicated.

You might be able to push the donor into making a smaller gift. But will they feel that you respected their decision? Will they feel comfortable having another conversation with you next year?

Probably not.

You may get a contribution in the short term, but you could damage the relationship in the process.

And that's the bigger issue.

Fundraising isn't just about getting a gift today. It's about creating authentic, aligned relationships that allow people to participate because they genuinely want to.

Your job is to do everything within your agency and then allow the donor's agency to begin.

That's the sweet spot between control and avoidance.

Three Questions to Help You Respond to Uncertainty

The next time you feel yourself wanting to over-follow up, push for an answer, or avoid a conversation altogether, I want you to pause.

Instead of immediately reacting, ask yourself these three questions.

1. What Am I Trying to Make Happen?

Be honest about the outcome you want.

Maybe you want the donor to give. Maybe you want the board to agree. Maybe you want a prospect to enroll in your program.

There is nothing wrong with wanting something.

The problem begins when you believe you must control the outcome in order to be okay.

You can hold two things to be true at the same time:

"I would really love this donor to make a significant gift, and I'm okay if they decide not to."

That is a much more grounded place from which to build a relationship.

2. What Am I Trying Not to Feel?

This is often the question that reveals whether you're responding through control or avoidance.

Are you afraid of rejection? Are you afraid of disappointing someone? Are you uncomfortable not knowing? Are you worried that doing nothing means you're not doing enough?

Sometimes our behavior has much more to do with managing our own emotions than responding to the actual situation.

When you can name the feeling, you can begin to separate it from the decision you need to make.

Feelings are uncomfortable sometimes, but they don't have to dictate your actions.

3. What Is Mine to Do Right Now?

Not what could I possibly do to make someone respond?

Not how can I get them to say yes?

What is genuinely yours to do?

Maybe you need to make a clear invitation. Maybe you need to have a courageous conversation. Maybe you need to communicate a boundary.

And maybe you've already done everything you can.

Sometimes the answer is nothing.

Not because you're avoiding the situation, but because you recognize that the next step belongs to someone else.

These three questions can help you distinguish between taking responsibility and trying to control something that isn't yours to control.

Why More Follow-Up Doesn't Always Mean Better Fundraising

We've been taught that persistence is everything in fundraising.

There's this idea that if you follow up a certain number of times, eventually someone will respond. Seven follow-ups, for example, have become a familiar rule of thumb in some fundraising conversations.

But I want us to question the thinking behind that approach.

Are we following up because we have something meaningful to contribute to the relationship? Or are we following up because we believe that enough attempts will eventually produce the answer we want?

No number of emails can guarantee another person's decision.

A donor isn't a puzzle you need to solve or a person you need to persuade into doing what you want.

When fundraising becomes a process of trying to control people's decisions, we lose sight of the relationship.

Instead, think about the conditions you're creating.

Does the donor feel informed? Do they understand the opportunity? Do they feel connected to the mission? Do they have the space to make an empowered decision? Do they know that their no will be respected?

We want to create relationships rooted in trust, connection, authenticity, and transparency.

We want donors to feel comfortable saying yes or no.

Because a meaningful yes is one that someone chooses freely.

Five Reminders for Fundraisers Navigating Uncertainty

Before we wrap up, here are five thoughts from this conversation that I want you to take with you:

  1. Control tries to escape uncertainty by doing more. When you find yourself over-following up or trying to force an answer, pause and examine what's driving your behavior.

  2. Avoidance tries to escape uncertainty by doing less. Not every decision to wait is trust. Sometimes you're simply afraid of what might happen if you act.

  3. You can want something deeply without needing to control it. It's okay to want the gift, the agreement, or the opportunity. You can still respect someone else's choice.

  4. Go all the way to the edge of your agency, but don't go beyond it. Do your part, make the invitation, communicate clearly, and allow the other person to do theirs.

  5. You don't need certainty about the outcome to have confidence in yourself. Your confidence comes from trusting your ability to navigate whatever happens next.

Fundraising Is About Creating the Conditions for Yes

Fundraising will always involve uncertainty.

We won't know exactly who will give, when someone will respond, or which relationships will develop into meaningful partnerships.

And that's okay.

Our responsibility isn't to eliminate uncertainty. It's to learn how to work within it.

You can care deeply about your mission without chasing every donor. You can make a compelling invitation without controlling the answer. You can accept a no without deciding that you've failed.

And you can trust yourself enough to know that whatever happens next, you'll figure it out.

Remember, control tries to make uncertainty disappear. Avoidance tries not to experience it. Trust allows you to remain present without needing to know how everything will turn out.

The goal isn't to control people into saying yes. It's to create the conditions where a yes becomes possible.

That means building relationships where people feel informed, connected, respected, and free to make their own choices.

You don't need to control the outcome. You need to trust yourself enough to do your part and release the rest.

Ready to Create More Flow in Your Fundraising?

If you're noticing that uncertainty is affecting how you communicate with donors, perhaps you're over-following up, hesitating to make invitations, or avoiding conversations because you're afraid of hearing no, I'd love to help.

Book a Donor Flow Call with me. We'll look at where your donors are in their journey, what's getting in the way of movement, and how you can create more meaningful connections without adding pressure.

Let's build fundraising relationships that feel aligned, authentic, honest, and transparent.

Because fundraising isn't about controlling people into saying yes. It's about creating the conditions where yes becomes possible.

Maryanne Dersch